<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 3.2 Final//EN"> <HTML> <HEAD> <META NAME="GENERATOR" CONTENT="LinuxDoc-Tools 0.9.21"> <TITLE>FAQ for isdn4linux: dod: Unwanted dialout on demand </TITLE> <LINK HREF="i4lfaq-17.html" REL=next> <LINK HREF="i4lfaq-15.html" REL=previous> <LINK HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16" REL=contents> </HEAD> <BODY> <A HREF="i4lfaq-17.html">Next</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq-15.html">Previous</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16">Contents</A> <HR> <H2><A NAME="dod"></A> <A NAME="s16">16.</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16">dod: Unwanted dialout on demand </A></H2> <H2><A NAME="dod_how"></A> <A NAME="ss16.1">16.1</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.1">dod_how: How does dialout on demand work? </A> </H2> <P>After you habe set up a network interface, and defined a route to it, then all ip packages will be routed to this interface. If the <CODE>autodial</CODE> mode has been enabled (see question <A HREF="i4lfaq-10.html#dialout_dialmode">dialout_dialmode</A> on the dialmodes) then the interface will automatically trigger a dialout when it receives ip packages. (This means that <B>any</B> user can trigger a dialout.)</P> <P>Example: You open a browser with no or a local homepage. Nothing happens. You enter some url to connect to, this will send ip packages to the network interface - thereby triggering a dialout.</P> <P>Using dial on demand is a potentially dangerous (means expensive) feature: see question <A HREF="#dod_disaster">dod_disaster</A>.</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_disaster"></A> <A NAME="ss16.2">16.2</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.2">dod_disaster: What is a charge unit disaster? </A> </H2> <P>The charge unit disaster can happen for many reasons (see question <A HREF="#dod_causes">dod_causes</A> for more details). However the results are identical: your computer dials out to your Internet Provider more often than you want, thereby increasing your telephone bill by a large amount (especially when you are not only charged for time online, but also a minimum amount/charge unit for every dialin). The term 'large amount' is rather flexible. Anything is possible: <UL> <LI>"Cheap": any DNS request opens the line, causing several dialouts per day (depending on your programs). If this happens 10 times a day, this makes up about 300 unneeded dialouts per month.</LI> <LI>"Not so cheap": Some Windows 95 computer in your LAN triggers a dialout every 15 minutes for one of its silly broadcasts (see question <A HREF="#dod_winclient">dod_win95</A>). Makes up 96 dialouts per day, or 2880 per month.</LI> <LI>"Medium": Your email client is configured to check every 5 minutes whether you have new emails at your Internet Service Provider. Makes up 288 dialouts per day, 8640 per month.</LI> <LI>"Expensive": Keep alive packets prevent that your line ever hangs up. Your line is always on. Note: THIS IS NOT THE WORST CASE!</LI> <LI>"More Expensive": Something goes wrong with dynamic addresses, leaving sockets open when hanging up. The sockets trigger another dialout when they try to resolve this, but since now you have a new ip address, the issue can't be resolved. The line will eventually hang up (when depends on your timeouts), but then re-open - since the sockets trigger another dialout. If you are unlucky, you never get the same ip address back, so this repeats continuously. Your line is almost always on, but on top of it you have to pay for many dialouts: if your timeout is 30 seconds, this makes up 2880 dialouts per day, 86400 per month.</LI> <LI>"Most Expensive - Worst Case": You misconfigure dialout/callback, so that when your (the initiating) computer dials out to your Internet Provider, who then hangs up on you (e.g. authorization failed - maybe he also has some misconfiguration or unhooks despite being down), your computer immediately dials out again. This is only limited by the amount of time needed to dial out. If we assume 2 seconds for each attempt (conservative estimate), this makes up 43200 dialouts per day, or 1296000 per month!</LI> </UL> </P> <P>This is no joke, and all these things have actually happened, even to real isdn4linux experts! See question <A HREF="#dod_off">dod_off</A> on how to avoid any risk of this happening to you.</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_causes"></A> <A NAME="ss16.3">16.3</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.3">dod_causes: What can cause a charge unit disaster? </A> </H2> <P>There are many possibilities. See question <A HREF="#dod_strategy">dod_strategy</A> on how to track down what is happening to you. See question <A HREF="#dod_disaster">dod_disaster</A> on how expensive that could be. Here a non-comprehensive list of causes: <OL> <LI>You compiled your kernel with the option Bridging by mistake.</LI> <LI>ARP requests or broadcasts? You should run ifconfig with the options <CODE>-arp</CODE> and <CODE>-broadcast</CODE> to keep from opening connections in this way. You can recognize this one when you have a dialout, but <EM>no</EM> data is transferred.</LI> <LI>Other Broadcasts from the interfaces were being forwarded by ISDN.</LI> <LI>If IP connections are still open with the line is disconnected and IP addresses are dynamically assigned, then the disaster is inevitable. Then a new connection is started to bring down the open IP connections, which fails because the IP address is now different. The line is hung up, but the IP connections are still open, the line is dialed again, and so on... This can only be avoided with the RST-provoking mode (see question <A HREF="#dod_rstprovoking">dod_rstprovoking</A>. A patch for it may be needed if it is not included in your distribution. The patch had found its way into the 2.0.x kernels, but not into 2.1/2.2/2.3. However, you can get an adjusted patch for 2.2.x kernels and some background information about it from: <A HREF="http://www.another.de/linux/router/">http://www.another.de/linux/router/</A>. See also question <A HREF="i4lfaq-12.html#syncppp_1stpacket">syncppp_1stpacket</A>. Also make sure to use ipppd's "defaultroute" option rather than <CODE>route add/del default</CODE> in ip-up/ip-down with it.</LI> <LI>TCP retries trigger dialout: when the kernel tries to send tcp packets and does not receive any answer, then it will retry to send them (usually every 120 seconds). Check out whether you want to adjust the following parameters: <UL> <LI>/proc/sys/net/ipv4/tcp_syn_retries</LI> <LI>/proc/sys/net/ipv4/tcp_retries1</LI> <LI>/proc/sys/net/ipv4/tcp_retries2</LI> </UL> Documentation can be found in <CODE>/usr/src/linux/Documentation/proc.txt</CODE>.</LI> <LI>Requests from your local DNS trigger a dialout: see question <A HREF="#dod_localdns">dod_localdns</A>.</LI> <LI>Sendmail triggers the dialout: see question <A HREF="#dod_sendmail">dod_sendmail</A>.</LI> <LI>Windows 95 clients trigger the dialout: see questions <A HREF="#dod_winclient">dod_win95</A>, <A HREF="#dod_localdns">dod_localdns</A>, and <A HREF="#dod_winclient">dod_win95b</A>.</LI> <LI>Samba triggers the dialout: see question <A HREF="#dod_samba">dod_samba</A>.</LI> <LI>Netscape triggers a dialout when started: see question <A HREF="#dod_netscape">dod_netscape</A>.</LI> <LI>dhcpd triggers dialouts: switch it off, and verify your configuration...</LI> <LI>Manually close IP connections which are still open when the line goes down: see question <A HREF="#dod_closeipconnect">dod_closeipconnect</A>.</LI> <LI>Your computer is crashed, but still processes interrupts: see question <A HREF="#dod_onlineoncrash">dod_onlineoncrash</A>.</LI> </OL> </P> <H2><A NAME="dod_off"></A> <A NAME="ss16.4">16.4</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.4">dod_off: How can I safely turn off dialout on demand? </A> </H2> <P> <OL> <LI>To always dial out manually, set your dialmode to <CODE>manual</CODE> (see question <A HREF="i4lfaq-10.html#dialout_dialmode">dialout_dialmode</A>). Then use <CODE>isdnctrl dial <device></CODE> to dial out, and <CODE>isdnctrl hangup <device></CODE> to hangup.</LI> <LI>Set your dialmode properly (see question <A HREF="i4lfaq-10.html#dialout_dialmode">dialout_dialmode</A>). For example, set dialmode to <CODE>manual</CODE> in <CODE>ip-down</CODE>. Then dialouts will only be possible once after setting dialmode to <CODE>auto</CODE>.</LI> <LI>Delete the telephone number of the interface, or set an invalid one. Then you can see from the complaints in the syslog whether a process wants to send packets out to the world.</LI> <LI>Switch the system off.</LI> <LI>Delete your route to the ISDN device. For example, to disable any automatic dialouts: <HR> <PRE> /sbin/route del default /sbin/isdnctrl system off /sbin/ifconfig ippp0 down </PRE> <HR> To get things running again: <HR> <PRE> /sbin/isdnctrl system on /sbin/ifconfig ippp0 up /sbin/route add $GATE-IP dev ippp0 /sbin/route add default ippp0 </PRE> <HR> The latter method has the disadvantage that dialin is then no longer possible.</LI> </OL> </P> <H2><A NAME="dod_strategy"></A> <A NAME="ss16.5">16.5</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.5">dod_strategy: How can I track down unexplainable dialouts? </A> </H2> <P>Finding the reason of unexpected dialouts is the first step to stopping it. However, finding is usually more difficult than fixing the problem. This is what you can do to track it down: <UL> <LI> First disconnect your dialout server from your LAN to find out who is responsible for the dialouts: the dialout server himself, or some clients in your LAN. For Windows clients, see question <A HREF="#dod_winclient">dod_winclient</A>.</LI> <LI> Try to find out which TCP/IP packet triggers the connection with "isdnctrl verbose 3". A message should appear in the kernel message queue (visible with <CODE>dmesg</CODE>), like: <CODE>OPEN: 141.76.60.54 - 193.171.67.253 TCP, port: 1686 - 540</CODE> In this example, our computer is trying to pick up mail on port 540 (UUCP over TCP/IP over ISDN) - the port number can be looked up in <CODE>/etc/services</CODE>. Please note: only the triggering packet will be logged.</LI> <LI> If you are using ipppd: get a tcpdump which can show data with the syncPPP encapsulation (this may require a patch - see question <A HREF="i4lfaq-7.html#trouble_tcpdump">trouble_tcpdump</A>).</LI> <LI> Try to turn off one daemon after the other and see if things have finally quieted down. named, sendmail, and also smbd (Samba) are likely candidates to open connections (see questions <A HREF="#dod_localdns">dod_localdns</A>, <A HREF="#dod_sendmail">dod_sendmail</A>, <A HREF="#dod_samba">dod_samba</A>).</LI> <LI> If broadcasts are your problem, you can also redirect the broadcast address to the dummy0 interface. It's not clean, but it works.</LI> </UL> </P> <H2><A NAME="dod_winclient"></A> <A NAME="ss16.6">16.6</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.6">dod_winclient: Can it be that the Win95 machine on my LAN is causing automatic dialouts? </A> </H2> <P>Yes. When Windows 3.11/95 is started, then it tries to talks to the name server of your provider (if known), trying to look up some domains (e.g. WORKGROUP.xxx). To avoid this, these are your options: <UL> <LI> Switch off the feature <CODE>Use DNS for Windows Names Resolution</CODE> on all Windows computers on your LAN.</LI> <LI> Set up a local DNS name server such that it will answer all requests. See question <A HREF="#dod_localdns">dod_localdns</A>.</LI> </UL> </P> <H2><A NAME="dod_localdns"></A> <A NAME="ss16.7">16.7</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.7">dod_localdns: I have set up a local DNS name server. Why does it cause unwanted dialouts? How can I find the cause? </A> </H2> <P>Turn on debug level 1 in named and look at the logfile in <CODE>/var/tmp</CODE>. Often, you can find regular DNS requests from Windows machines. The problem is that names like "WORKGROUP.domain.de" are requested, i.e. names that the DNS could not know. Windows seems to be looking for its master browser or a domain controller (if you are fluent in German, see ct 12/99, page 224: "Schnitzeljagd - Netzwerkumgebung und Browserdienst im Windows-Netzwerk" for more details). To work around this problem, you can set up your domain name server with cname = "WORKGROUP.domain.de" (other domain names are also possible). Or set up a Primary Domain Controller within your LAN. You can also use diald to control dialouts for DNS request.</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_forwarddns"></A> <A NAME="ss16.8">16.8</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.8">dod_forwarddns: I have set up my name server in 'forward' mode, with one forward address. Now it dials out about every minute? </A> </H2> <P>From time to time, the name server will query its forwarder, which will trigger a dialout. Since your ISP uses dynamic ip addresses, the request is sent out with the wrong ip address at startup of the dial-in connection. Therefore, no answer will be received. Bind waits for one minute before resubmitting. If your line has come down in the mean time, this will trigger a new dialout, resulting in a different ip address, and so on...</P> <P>For a workaround to this problem you can shorten the retransmission time as described in question <A HREF="i4lfaq-10.html#dialout_bind">dialout_bind</A>.</P> <P>Alternatively, you can set the option "dialup yes;" in the options block of named.conf. This will cause named to do only one interaction with a forwarder (triggering a dod) at startup. After that it will wait for some very long interval (24h?) before another query with the forwarder. Only during actual lookup it will do negotiations with the forwarder (this is usually when you have already dialed out anyway).</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_sendmail"></A> <A NAME="ss16.9">16.9</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.9">dod_sendmail: How can I get sendmail to not initiate any connections without local mail being left undelivered? </A> </H2> <P>First you have to get sendmail to no long open any DNS connections. You need to activate the following features: "nodns", "nocanonify".</P> <P>If you have a smarthost, you need to make sure that this name does not call the name server. You can either set it directly as an IP address, or add the name to /etc/hosts (/etc/host.conf should then contain "order hosts bind")</P> <P>You should set all non-local mailers as "expensive" ("define(SMTP_MAILER_FLAGS, e)"), and then forbid sendmail with "define(`confCON_EXPENSIVE', `True')" from automatically connection to expensive mailers. The call to sendmail should no longer include a time for the "-q" option (e.g. only "-bd -os -q"). "-os" means that all mail will be queued (which won't prevent local mail from being delivered immediately). The only catch is that when booting, mail that might still be in the queue will be sent by sendmail, even though the network is not yet up. Therefore, when booting you should remove all mail from /var/mqueue before starting sendmail, and then return it once sendmail has been started.</P> <P>Mail to expensive mailers will now only be send with the explicit call "sendmail -q".</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_samba"></A> <A NAME="ss16.10">16.10</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.10">dod_samba: The samba package always triggers dialouts for me. How can I prevent this? </A> </H2> <P>When nmbd starts up it tries to bind to 0.0.0.0 or all interfaces, which is what triggers the ISDN dialup. The best way to solve this is to set "bind interfaces only = yes" and "interfaces = eth0" in smb.conf (in case you want to use Samba only in your LAN). Alternatively, you can give the samba daemon an internal ip address upon startup. First find out which ip address samba is trying to connect to (e.g. with netstat or tcpdump). Then start samba with: <HR> <PRE> nmdb -S -B 192.168.99.255 -I 192.168.99.99 </PRE> <HR> if your Linux computer has 192.168.99.99 as ip address, and all users are in the same subnet (192.168.99.255).</P> <P>See also the above question: set -broadcast and possibly -arp when defining the interfaces!</P> <P>Check out the help pages for the Samba configuration file for further possibilities on preventing dialout (I was told there should be some explicit dialup parameter which prevents it to cause many dialouts).</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_netscape"></A> <A NAME="ss16.11">16.11</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.11">dod_netscape: How can I get Netscape to quit initiating dialouts when starting? </A> </H2> <P>Most likely in the preferences a non-local home page has been listed. Only a home page that Netscape is able to load immediately (e.g. "file://localhost/xxx") won't cause an immediate dialout. Alternatively you can also set up a cache daemon that saves pages that are often needed.</P> <P>Second check your proxy settings. When giving a complete name instead of an ip address, Netscape may try to do a DNS lookup to resolve the name to an ip address on startup. In this case provide Netscape with an ip address.</P> <P>Another thing is that Netscape tries to contact its news server. If you don't want to use this feature then you can enter the name Netscape uses for lookup (probably 'news') in your local DNS or in your /etc/hosts, and let it point to localhost.</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_rstprovoking"></A> <A NAME="ss16.12">16.12</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.12">dod_rstprovoking: Why should I use the RST-provoking mode/patch? </A> </H2> <P>If on every dialup (in auto dialout mode) you get a different ip address (dynamic ip), and the dialup connection gets terminated (e.g due to inactivity) while some ip connections have not yet been closed, then the following problem will occur: when the program tries to close the connection this will trigger a new dialout. Since this will yield in a new ip address, the closing attempt will fail. After the timeout period another dialout will be attempted, with the same result, leading to a dial on demand disaster. To prevent this problem the RST-provoking mode has been invented. If on the closing attempt a new dialout is opened and the ip address changes, then the kernel will send a ip packet with the reset flag on. This will close down the open connection, preventing the dial on demand disaster. To activate the RST-provoking mode use the command <HR> <PRE> echo 7 > /proc/sys/net/ipv4/ip_dynaddr </PRE> <HR> Use 5 instead of 7 to prevent syslog warnings. Check the current status with: <HR> <PRE> cat /proc/sys/net/ipv4/ip_dynaddr </PRE> <HR> Your distribution may or may not have the patch for this rst-provoking mode included, it was not liked in the kernel code for kernels newer than 2.0.x.</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_closeipconnect"></A> <A NAME="ss16.13">16.13</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.13">dod_closeipconnect: After closing the line, I discover with <CODE>netstat -nt</CODE> that IP connections are still open. How can I close these manually? </A> </H2> <P>This may only work with the RST-provoking mode (mentioned in question <A HREF="#dod_causes">dod_causes</A>): You can bring the interface "down" then back "up". When you do this, it will try to dial out. But if you have removed the outgoing telephone number, then "no outgoing number..." appears in the syslog, and as soon as the interface is "up", all connections will be closed.</P> <P>You can prevent those open IP connections to trigger new dialouts if you add a special firewall rule in <CODE>/etc/ppp/ip-down</CODE>, and remove it in <CODE>/etc/ppp/ip-up</CODE>. This firewall rule drops all tcp packets which are not in SYNSENT state. Add this in <CODE>/etc/ppp/ip-down</CODE> for a 2.2.x kernel: <HR> <PRE> ipchains -A output -j DENY -p tcp -i <interface> ! -y </PRE> <HR> Add this in <CODE>/etc/ppp/ip-up</CODE>: <HR> <PRE> ipchains -A output -j DENY -p tcp -i <interface> ! -y </PRE> <HR> (As is the case for all firewall rules: it is best to put this into a separate script which is called with either a start or a stop parameter.) Please note that this firewall rule only matches whole packets, no fragments. A fragment will always bypass the firewall and trigger a dialout.</P> <H2><A NAME="dod_onlineoncrash"></A> <A NAME="ss16.14">16.14</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16.14">dod_onlineoncrash: Is it possible that even with a crashed computer a ISDN connection remains open (and the charge units accumulate)? </A> </H2> <P>The ISAC chipset, which is in use on many ISDN cards, can be run in either auto mode, or in non-auto mode. When run in auto mode, the connection could be up when the computer is crashed (the card keeps it up and running). Since the HiSax driver uses nonauto mode, this should not happen with ISDN4LINUX. Once no interrupt is processed on your machine, the connection will stop at maximum half a minute later. Only in the unlikely event that your machine is crashed, while interrupts are still processed normally, this could happen.</P> <HR> <A HREF="i4lfaq-17.html">Next</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq-15.html">Previous</A> <A HREF="i4lfaq.html#toc16">Contents</A> </BODY> </HTML>
